Summer Series: Realigning the Conferences Based on Geography
Welcome to the first ever Cowboy Altitude summer series. An entertaining way to spend your summer as we countdown the start of football season.
Conference realignment has been a huge story the last couple years and it continues to make headlines. Most of it involves the BCS Conferences trying to strengthen themselves in order to sign large media deals and weaken smaller conferences. Some other conferences are trying to add schools in order to stay legitimate organizations and keep afloat in this competitive world.
I didn't want to do a story about the current alignment scenarios that are happening. Instead I wanted to do a series on a different reason that conferences would realign. Since summer is here and the news may be slow over the next couple months we will stretch this series out with a new portion every week. The concept behind the idea is below as well as a schedule for when the new posts will be released. It is a fairly realistic scenario that could happen but hopefully would never actually occur.
SCENARIO:
The United States is plunged into a huge energy crisis and the cost of oil skyrockets. Think of what happened back in the 70's and multiply it a couple times. There are gas shortages everywhere and the price of a gallon of petrol reaches double digits. One of the largest expenses for universities is travel for teams which can include airfare, bus rides, food and hotel rooms.
Energy conversation becomes so important that the government puts restrictions on citizens, businesses and sports teams (college and professional). The NCAA is given two options with it's sports programs: cancel all intercollegiate athletics or realign conferences based on region in order to reduce travel of athletic teams as much as possible.
Gone are the days of the WAC that spans from California to Louisiana and the Big East would no longer extend west of the Mississippi.
There are only one a couple rules for this scenario:
- The smaller the conference the better
- Only D1 FBS Schools
- No more independent schools
- Keep the 11 current conferences (We will give them new names)
This also gives me an opportunity to combine two of my favorite things: college football and staring at maps. Yes, I'm an atlas nerd and proud of it.
So the structure of the college football will stay essentially the same and we will be using the current 120 FBS schools that are active in 2011. Some conferences will be larger or smaller based on the geography of the region. Also championship games are out now since it would require an extra game and extra travel. So there may be a conference of 11 schools which is some thing you would normally not see.
It will be very interesting to see each conference is put together and what the strengths of weaknesses of each would be in real life. We will breakdown the pluses and minuses eachly reformed league and how it compares to the current one.
Here is our schedule for when each new conference post will be released:
Week 1: Intro Post - (You are here)
Week 4: Mountain West lives up to it's name
Week 6: Conference USA shrinks
Week 13: Series recap and NCAA 12 Simulation Results
These new conferences will feature programs of every level and create some very interesting rivalries or renew some old ones. You should bookmark this site if you haven't already so that you can make sure you don't miss each conference as it is released. There are obviously plenty of ways to start but I ended up choosing the western United States as a starting point and then moving eastward. Schools are more spread out in the west so it can be an easier starting point.
Another bonus is that Jim Delany and Larry Scott have no power in this scenario. By the time this series is finished fall practice will have started and we will be on the verge of college football starting up. Hope you enjoy the series and it helps your summer go by a little bit quicker.
10 comments
|
4 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Looking forward to this
Mountain West Connection The best site for MWC sports!
SB Nation Denver
Follow me on twitter!
Inside The Utes
Can't wait
to see how this unfolds. I’ve been kicking around conference realignment scenarios for when the new NCAA Football game.
"No Mission Too Difficult, No Sacrifice Too Great—Duty First" - 1st Infantry Division Motto
SB Nation Denver - The regional hub for Denver sports!
Purple Row - Covering all your Rockies needs!
Glad you guys are excited about this project.
I’ve been planning this one for awhile. Hope it turns out well….
Cowboy Altitude - Coverage of the Wyoming Cowboys
"This also gives me an opportunity to combine two of my favorite things: college football and staring at maps. Yes, I'm an atlas nerd and proud of it."
Rec’d.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
by TheMattROb on Jun 22, 2011 12:11 PM MDT reply actions
I have enjoyed reading your first four installments.
As someone who is also a fan of college football and maps, I wonder how your process would have turned out if the constraints were even greater.
What if you were required to minimize travel even more by combining all 238 Division I football schools (FBS + FCS)?
Imagining a scenario with 16 conferences with auto-bids to a playoff, each conference would need an average of 14.875 teams. So, we’d need a mix of 14-team and 16-team conferences.
If you ever care to tackle this project again with new parameters I’d like to see the end result.
That is quite the project to undertake.
We’ll see how the rest of this project goes. Then see what have planned for summer of 2012.
Cowboy Altitude - Coverage of the Wyoming Cowboys
Interesting, but ...
I like your idea, but think it would be more fun if you used some discretion in combining teams. Keeping AQs and non-AQs in separate conferences for the most part (the top non-AQs could move up or the bottom AQs move down) would be more realistic and adds some constraints.
Are you going to actually prove that you have minimized travel, or just assume it?
Anyway, things should get especially interesting when you get to the southeast and midwest.
In each post I post I list the farthest distances in the new conference.
Conference games make up a majority of the travel for college teams. If San Jose State no longer has to make annual trips to Louisiana and plays other California schools more. Then there would definitely be a reduction in travel.
Cowboy Altitude - Coverage of the Wyoming Cowboys
I love almost everything about this!
I am very excited to see this done; there are a number of advantages to this that aren’t immediately apparent beyond geography. The one that seems to already be coming out of these (I’ve come into this late, in week 7) is a better distribution of power. Each geography-based conference will have very very good teams and very very weak ones. I like the redistribution of power such that it enables greater competition and there are more chances for real upsets.
We’ve gone through an era when the college football powers have risen and fallen; Stanford was atrocious fairly recently and Washington State played in the Rose Bowl in this century, as impossible as that seems to be now. It is not inconceivable for a team from our MAC, WAC, or Sun Belt to rise to the top of a conference with an Ohio State, USC, or LSU. Even baring that, competing for the second or third spot in a conference with Texas Tech or Colorado and New Mexico State and UTEP makes for some interesting possibilities.
My only real criticism of this is your seemingly arbitrary limitation to eleven conferences. This seems to me unnecessary, seeing as how you are completely and radically reworking the entire system of college football from the bottom up, reconfiguring all of the conferences such that the old rules become essentially meaningless. Your decision to saddle yourself with an imposition that only works to hinder your final outcome seems problematic and you may find that a larger number of conferences each with a smaller number of teams is more effective at attaining a more satisfying outcome.
by SanFranciscoStateGaters on Jul 20, 2011 12:14 AM MDT reply actions
In regards to eleven conferences that was mainly done to work within the confines of current college football and keep some history.
It also allows for the new conferences to be simmed in NCAA 12 which will happen at the end of the series. Going with more conferences like 12 or 13 certainly would be possible if a scenario like this did occur.
Cowboy Altitude - Coverage of the Wyoming Cowboys

by 









